THE FIFTH ESTATE
The World Wide Web

 

Klee. "The embrace".

The World Wide Web is a new medium.

It is akin to the newspapers of last century, and it is different.

These links were collected after South Australian magistrates were provided with limited access to the World Wide Web.

As the magistrates grappled with the WWW, some began to ask the author questions about the nature of the medium itself.

The easiest way to answer their questions was to email a copy of this file, a file to help them find their own answers. It has grown out of collaboration between work colleagues.

What is "the Web"?

The World Web transports information between computers connected to the Internet. It is used to get around the obstacles which incompatible
hardware creates. Files are "glued" into packages which any hardware can cope with.

The WWW has emerged as a result of simple negotiated agreements about standards. The agreements are adhered to in every jurisdiction
reached by the Internet.

The agreements are enforceable in none of these jurisdictions. Compliance often brings economic rewards; non-compliance brings isolation and economic demise.

A common language of text based terms (" html tags") has been agreed upon, and is regularly revised, by academic and technical experts who participate in the World Wide Web Consortium. A new central agreement, the fourth updating of the standards, is currently nearing completion.

These agreements have no legal standing, although many other consequential agreements
a) rely on the WWW agreements; and
b) have legal standing within particular jurisdictions.

The tags are then used to design "server software", "html files", and "browsers".

When "html files" are stored on a "server" computer connected to the Internet, other software ("browsers") use the html tags to access the information on the "server". The "browser" then prints the text, sound and graphics on the screen of the "client" computer, which is also connected to the Internet.

The WWW has largely replaced the old university data storage sites, which used "gopher" and "file transfer protocol".

Why is there so much rubbish on the WWW?

The graphical face of the WWW has brought commercialisation and the public relations consultant to the Internet, formerly the exclusive domain of the military and the universities. The traditional student's home page, a learning exercise, has been replaced by an endless "graffiti wall" of personal homepages, a place where anyone with Internet access can mark the fact of their existence in cyberspace.

Few organisations have coped well.

  • People working with the web are often
    obsessed: either with information content,
    or with appearance, without regard to content.
  • Managers do not understand the medium.

Data specialists, emulating textbooks which have economic limits on space and colour, serve up information without regard any but the most basic features of presentation. The information comes in black or navy, in 12 point 'Times New Roman' font, on a grey or white background, without sound or movement. It looks like this section of this file.

Graphic artists, used to hard copy and television, are infuriated by their inability to dictate the final appearance of the page which reaches the reader. Often they are too distracted to look beyond technology, to look at content.

The result has been a proliferation of electronic propaganda on billboards which needlessly repeat obsolete limitations. Billboards which contain the fax number of the relevant branch of the department, but not the email address.

Governments and "good corporate citizens" are usually the worst offenders when it comes to the crime of wasting time and bandwidth. Courts are no exception. Enormous amounts of money are wasted in the process.

Who gets some "Brownie Points"?

Two very different Australian legal sites are supplying quality information which is nicely set out.

Both site administrators are using the Internet to get information out to the people involved implementation, such as the people in and around the courts, people who are not working in the areas of academic research or legislative policy.

Low Budget

Early in 1997 the Australian Institute of Criminology stopped using external consultants and put their web pages in the hands of their research librarian, John Myrtle. At home at night he taught himself to use html tags. Then he began the long arduous process of developing a site the hard way, building it by using a conventional commercial word processing package. The elves and their houses, in combination with the quality of the information, make this site.

To see the elves, enter here:
The Australian Institute of Criminology

High Budget

At Window on the Law, they do their level best to keep on getting the latest law and news out to those of us on the road to Bordertown.

This is the Australian Attorney-General's web site.

It publishes press releases, it is home to ScalePlus, the electronic law library which made our electronic public law libraries possible, and it is the home of the Advisory Councils which are charged with making the recommendations which will taking the Australian legal system into the next century.

David Grainger is the person at the end of their email address. On top of the rest of his work, he bats the email queries coming in.

COMMUNICATIONS

  1. Lobbying
    The Other Side of the Wall (obsolete link)
    The death penalty & prison reform. US.
  2. Appeals to the court of public opinion
    Afro-American prisoners.(obsolete link) US.
  3. Advertising
    WLR Cassidy & Associates (obsolete link)
    Former CIA operatives, now
    Asian crime consultants. US.
  4. Interactive Entertainmment
    The Internet Virtual Prison (obsolete link)
  5. Judicial Accountability
    Judge's Hall Of Shame
  6. Anecdotes
    News (obsolete link)
    The Investigators Australia newsletter
  7. Public Information
    DPP (Cwlth) Home Page
  8. Witness Information
    THE COURT SERVICE CHARTER (obsolete link)
    FOR COURT USERS: Witnesses (obsolete link)
    UK.
  9. Court Lists
    COUNTY COURT CRIME LISTS (obsolete link)
    Victoria
    Foundation Law - Australian Court Lists
  10. Progress bulletins
    High Court Bulletin - No.8 1997
  11. TalkBack
    Talk to Us (obsolete link)
    Office of the Status of Women
    Department of the Prime Minister
    and Cabinet
  12. Public Education
    http://www.cnet.com/
    CNet computer network

THE WWW LIBRARY

  1. Primary Law Resources
    AustLII Databases
  2. Law Journals: Primary Publishing
    JILT (obsolete link)
    Open Access to Legal Sources in Australasia
    by Judith Bannister
    ELaw
    Legal Expert Systems:
    A Humanistic Critique of
    Mechanical Legal Inference
    by Andrew Greinke
  3. Law Journals: Secondary Publishing
    The Melbourne University Law Review
    Volume 19 No. 3 (obsolete link)
    The meaning of proportionality in sentencing
    By Richard G Fox
  4. Practitioner publishing
    Lawnet Texts: The Culture of Sentencing: (obsolete link)
    NickPapas
  5. The Academic Syllabus
    UniServe Law - Course Materials (obsolete link)
    Curricula and lecture notes
  6. Government Reports
    Australian Law Reform Commission-
    Report 69
    (obsolete link)
    Equality before the Law- Women- Part 1
  7. Keeping up with new caselaw
    SCiB #28 (obsolete link)
    Mr. Peter Faris QC's headnotes bulletin.
    New Supreme Court cases from around
    the world
  8. Autobiographies
    Dead Man Talkin'. by Dean (obsolete link)
  9. Fiction/Satire
    Center For Shopping Cart Abuse
    Prevention & Study
  10. Collaboration
    Professor Stubbs's Criminology Post
    Swapping URL.s on a mailing list
  11. Relaying research results to the
    implementers
    Australian Institute of Criminology
    Documents and Reports Index
  12. Law news & caselaw
    Court TV Law Center
    Broadsheet or tabloid?
  13. Joke Repositories
    Q: How do you greet a lawyer with an IQ of 50?
    A: "Good morning, your honor."
  14. Grubby Pictures (obsolete link)
    Porn site. Relatively tame compared to some of the others though just as deficient in quality photgraphy
  15. Love-Penn (obsolete link)
    Sites like this have wrecked the market some U.S. women prisoners found: that men would pay to send them email while they served their sentences.
  16. Two sides
    Art Crimes: Melbourne Trains
    He's promised send more pictures over to this US site, (which also has some fabulous art links in its Phat List)
    Tagnet (obsolete link)
    US police. Graffiti buster site.

SEARCHING THE INTERNET

Internet Resources: Guides and Navigation Aids (obsolete link)
The Australian National Library

  1. Catalogues
    CataLaw
    Excellent US directory
  2. Search Engines
    Search Engines: What they Are,
    How They Work, and
    Practical Suggestions for
    Getting the Most Out of Them
    General introduction
    LawRunner Australia:
    A Legal Research Tool
    FindLaw - LawCrawler (obsolete link)
    The front runner. US site, worldwide resources.
  3. Multi- disciplinary directories
    FSU School of Criminology Criminal Justice Links (obsolete link)
    Cecil Greek's famous criminology links.

 

Klee. "The embrace".

 

A useful rule of thumb for site design is "copy the great chefs".

Good chefs take care to make their food taste terrific. They don't ruin the effect by dumping food on plates.

In site building, the taste of the food is in the information the site contains. The indexing of the pages, the search tools, the graphics, the sounds: these are the plates.