audio visual Technology and victorian courts

 

Video Linking

Vision for the Future

To provide an integrated audio/visual system that can cater for remands, recalcitrant accused persons, circuit early arraignments, circuit civil directions hearings and remote witness requirements as well as put in place an infrastructure that will provide full video conferencing capability to any courtroom using I.S.D.N. technology which will provide world wide connectivity creating greater access to justice at a cheaper cost for litigants.

Current Situation

 

Remands

Prisoners can remain at gaol and therefore eliminate or reduce transport costs, security risks and minimise disruption to prisoners.

Pre Hearing Conference Interlocutory Proceedings

Solicitors and their clients interact with the court from any location and have access to the judiciary for circuit early arraignments, circuit directions hearings and other interlocutory steps on a daily basis without the judge, practitioners and litigants having to travel.

Remote/Protected Witness

Current remote witness system requires witness to give evidence from an office within the court building but outside the actual court room. This facility also provides unlimited opportunities for expert witnesses and protected witnesses to be able to provide evidence quickly, securely and cost effectively from any location world wide.

Expert Witness

Currently it is very costly to provide this type of evidence which occurs most commonly in medical/forensic science areas. Facility enables organisations like Police Forensic Science Laboratories as well as private practitioners to increase their productivity by reducing travel time and makes it more affordable to use intrastate, interstate and overseas experts.

Remote appearance by Counsel (DPP, VLA, etc)

There are instances whereby lawyers can adequately fulfil their duties remote from the court, increase accessibility and raise productivity utilising video conference technology.

The pilot programs identified the following limitations:

 

The Personal Contact

Video conferencing will never replace the personal contact in the court room which the judiciary and court users feel is needed in some areas. It will only provide an alternative for those matters where such contact may not be critical to the running of a case.

Technical Breakdown

Like any technology, computers can malfunction and will require appropriate support.

Legislation

The Evidence (Audio Visual and Audio Linking) Act came into operation in December 1997. It enables the judiciary to direct that a person appear by audio or audio visual link from any place within or outside Victoria or outside Australia.

Current Roll-Out of Equipment

From January 1998 to October 1998 video conferencing facilities will be installed at the Melbourne County Court (22 criminal courtrooms and 4 civil courtrooms), Melbourne Magistrates' Court (4 courtrooms), Supreme Court, Boards and Tribunals, Children's Court and the Coroner's Court, as well as country courts at Warrnambool, Geelong, Ballarat, Bendigo, Mildura, Shepparton, Wangaratta, Moe and Morwell. Save for Morwell (solely a County Court) and Moe (solely a Magistrates' Court), at all other country locations the facility will be available within the one court building in both the higher jurisdiction court and the Magistrates' Court, along with the protected witness room.

The Department of Justice has also installed equipment at the Police Forensic Science Laboratories and three private prisons.

 

REMOTE RECORDING

Vision for the Future

To provide an integrated audio visual system which enables courts to be recorded for the purpose of producing a transcript without the need to have a recorder operator in the courtroom. Court proceedings will be recorded using audio and video technology. Video and audio signals will be transmitted to VGRS which will act as a central hub. Transcription can be undertaken by either VGRS staff or private contractors.

Current Situation

The pilot programs have demonstrated the following strengths:

Recorder Operator in Court

Video recording equipment removes the need to have a recorder operator in court. One recorder operator monitors two courts remotely from VGRS.

Remote Diagnostics

VGRS staff have the ability to electronically fault find, diagnose and remedy technical problems remotely.

I.S.D.N. Links

These links remove the need to have audio typists or reporters on site at each country location for the purpose of transcription.

Staff Flexibility

The technology gives VGRS much more flexibility in the use of its staff by bringing all transcription back to a central location which enables downtime to be minimised.

Service Equity

The technology enables the judiciary and circuit litigants at those circuit courts to receive equivalent service levels enjoyed in the C.B.D. in circuit locations.

The pilot programs have identified the following limitations:

 

Personal Contact

It is more difficult to obtain supporting information required for transcript production such as spellings, etc. VGRS requires appropriate support and cooperation from the court end users.

Technical Breakdown

Computers and telephone networks can malfunction and require appropriate support.

 

 

Current Roll Out of Equipment

From January 1998 to May 1998 video recording facilities will be installed at twenty-two criminal courts at Melbourne County Court, the majority of which installation work has now been completed. Training of Tipstaves and Recorder Operators will take place from March onwards with commissioning in each courtroom following the individual training.

The software that will provide the switching between recording, video conferencing, P.A. system and closed circuit protected witness system to be controlled by a tablet in the courtroom by the tipstaff and remotely by VGRS staff with remote diagnostic functionality.

 

World First

We have been advised that this integrated audio/visual system is a world first and the V-Tel Corporation has indicated a willingness to onsell this system as a partner with the Department of Justice.

In 1997 Victoria hosted an international court reporting conference that was attended by delegates from America, Canada, Asia, New Zealand, Africa as well as Australia. At the "State of the Nation" session it was apparent that Victoria is a world leader in court reporting and its use of technology.

 

OTHER EMERGING AUDIO/VISUAL TECHNOLOGIES THAT WILL IMPACT ON COURTS

Voice Recognition Software

VGRS has piloted "Dragon Dictate" and "Naturally Speaking" software packages. Justice Teague and Master Kings from the Supreme Court have also "road tested" the technology. Whilst an exciting breakthrough, it is not stable enough nor does it enable an experienced user to complete transcription tasks with sufficient speed to replace existing work practices at present. The ongoing testing of this software will continue through VGRS.

Digital Recording

A number of systems are available. VGRS have investigated several. At present the systems have not proved cost effective to justify extensive implementation.

 

 

 

....................................

G.R.D. Waldron

Chief Judge

County Court

....................................

D.A.T. Jones

Judge

County Court

....................................

Mr Clive Alsop

Magistrate

 

....................................

Mr Mick Francis

General Manager

Victorian Government Reporting Service